The Washington PostDemocracy Dies in Darkness

Tom Jones, co-creator of stage landmark ‘The Fantasticks,’ dies at 95

Show was the longest-running musical in U.S. theater history, with more than 17,160 performances

August 15, 2023 at 4:59 p.m. EDT
Tom Jones in New York in 2011. (Walter McBride/Corbis/Getty Images)
7 min

Minutes before midnight on May 3, 1960, the creators of a modest, two-act musical, “The Fantasticks,” waited for the reviews after opening night at a theater in New York’s Greenwich Village. The consensus among the critics was that there was no consensus.

The New York Times theater reviewer Brooks Atkinson called the first act “delightful” but added that the story of young lovers and meddlesome fathers “loses magic the longer it endures.” Other critics praised the minimalist staging and clever use of a narrator as an oracle-like storyteller.