Robin Hood TV and film adaptations ranked by historical accuracy from Disney to the Prince of Thieves

Robin Hood, the legendary outlaw who stole from the rich to give to the poor, has been a beloved character in folklore for centuries.

Over the years, numerous movies have been made, each offering its unique take on the famous archer. However, the question remains: how true are these adaptations to the real story of Robin Hood?

While no adaptation can claim to be entirely true to the real story, many manage to capture the essence and spirit of the legend. The accuracy of each adaptation largely depends on its specific aims, whether that's to entertain, provide a fresh perspective, or offer a more historically grounded narrative.

So we asked ChatGPT to rank the many renditions of Robin Hood and his Merry Men based on historical accuracy - and this was the outcome. Do you agree?

(Ranking from least accurate to most accurate)

Disney's Robin Hood (1973)

Disney's take on the legendary outlaw is a unique and beloved adaptation. In this animated film, anthropomorphic animals fill the roles of the traditional characters, with Robin Hood portrayed as a charming fox.

The story is simplified for a family-friendly audience, but it retains the core elements of the legend, including the battle against the villainous Sheriff of Nottingham.

Historical Accuracy: 1/5

Robin Hood: Men in Tights (1993)

A comedic parody of the Robin Hood myth, directed by Mel Brooks, this film takes great creative license for humour's sake.

While not intended to be historically accurate, it does hilariously poke fun at the various clichés and inaccuracies found in other adaptations.

Historical Accuracy: 1/5

Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves (1991)

Starring Kevin Costner as Robin Hood, this adaptation takes creative liberties by including an American-accented hero and a Moorish companion, Azeem.

While some elements diverge from historical reality, it maintains the spirit of the legend, focusing on Robin's fight against the oppressive Sheriff of Nottingham.

Historical Accuracy: 2/5

Robin Hood (1997 TV Movie)

This TV movie, starring Devon Sawa as Robin Hood, takes creative liberties while still adhering to some of the traditional Robin Hood narratives. It doesn't strive for historical accuracy but maintains the spirit of the legend.

Historical Accuracy: 2/5

Robin and Marian (1976):

Starring Sean Connery and Audrey Hepburn as an aging Robin Hood and Maid Marian, this film offers a unique take on the legend.

While not striving for historical accuracy, it explores the characters' later years and the realities of their aging.

Historical Accuracy: 2/5

Robin Hood (2010)

Directed by Ridley Scott and starring Russell Crowe, this adaptation aimed to present a more historically grounded version of the legend. It portrays Robin as a soldier returning from the Crusades and maintains a grittier, more realistic tone.

However, it still incorporates many fictional elements and lacks the traditional charm of the legend.

Historical Accuracy: 2.5/5

Robin Hood (2018)

Starring Taron Egerton as Robin Hood and Jamie Foxx as Little John, this version offers a unique, modernized take on the legend. It introduces political intrigue and a more revolutionary Robin, yet still keeps the core elements of the story alive.

Historical Accuracy: 2.5/5

The Adventures of Robin Hood (1938)

Directed by Michael Curtiz and William Keighley, this classic film starring Errol Flynn remains one of the most iconic adaptations of the Robin Hood legend. Set in medieval England, it captures the essence of the tale, with Flynn's charismatic portrayal of Robin Hood being both swashbuckling and chivalrous.

While not entirely historically accurate, it's a faithful representation of the legend, with archery contests, Sherwood Forest, and the struggle against Prince John.

Historical Accuracy: 3/5